We love these photo studio illustrations with the studio name appearing multiple times (eight in this case, including the name under the building). The block on the sidewalk is called a carriage step, carriage stone or mounting block, if you were wondering. The above is the reverse of the Cabinet Card in the prior post.
Most of what appears presently online for Edward F. Hartley (1847 – 1887) comes from obituaries; some of the information we found conflicts, that being his year of marriage, studio location prior to Chicago (Jacksonville or Decatur but no record was found of either in city directories or newspaper ads) and whether he competed for professional photographer association prizes. In any case, Hartley was a very successful and well-known Chicago photographer whose studio was located at 309 W. Madison Street since at least 1877. The son of Methodist minister Charles Hartley and his wife Louisa (Louisa’s given name per the 1850 Federal Census; however her maiden name wasn’t located.) Edward Hartley was born in Wadsworth, Ohio, on November 9, 1847, (per the Daily Inter-Ocean.) On October 5, 1871 (or 1873) he married a judge’s daughter, Virginia Boyd; they had no children. Below an excerpt from Edgar E. Boyd’s Record of the Boyd Family: John Boyd from Scotland and Descendants, which was compiled in 1913:
Below, two obituaries, from, left to right, from the Decatur Daily Republican (Decatur, IL) and the Daily Inter Ocean (Chicago, IL) and a funeral announcement from the Inter Ocean.
Below, a humorous analogy in advertisement by E. F. Hartley, showing the shrewd businessman in action. The “Sign of the Rooster” mentioned at the bottom of the ad, can be seen in other ads put out by him, as in the insert below, a rooster standing atop another rooster, victorious. (We found another, showing Hartley’s rooster having completely beaten down the competition. That one was too graphic for our sensibilities, and we remind ourselves that this was the 1880s…probably what we today would view as negative in advertising (therefor to avoid) was perhaps just seen as getting the point across. The dogs at the trough image is a little rough, too. No pun intended 😉 As for the $2.00 Cabinet Cards, this price was for twelve Cabinets and one panel, a smokin’ hot deal for the public, to be sure.
Below, from a couple of our readers (thank you!)….see the comment from J. Hill. Here’s the beautiful shadow box and a close-up in sepia of the handsome, newly-married couple, names unknown, photographed by the Hartley studio. Note the bride’s lace at the neck (unusual by today’s standards I think, because it’s not symmetrical) love her dark gloves, the beautiful embroidery on the bodice…and very unusual, that white piece of fabric sticking out below the bodice, seemingly so random, but in a way balancing out the lace on the neck in the overall effect. And those would be artificial orange blossoms (most likely made from wax) in the bride’s headpiece and the groom’s boutonniere, that now lovingly surround the Cabinet Card. Orange blossoms were worn and made popular by Queen Victoria at her wedding to her beloved Prince Albert.
Update: In response to a query from a reader, for the question of whether the Hartley studio continued after his death in 1887….There is a possibility that Edward’s brother, Charles F. may have continued with the business, more research will be forthcoming. Below, the news clipping on Hartley’s will appearing in Chicago’s The Inter Ocean:
Sources: Ancestry.com. Illinois, Marriage Index, 1860-1920.
Year: 1850; Census Place: Lawrence, Stark, Ohio; Roll: M432_731; Page: 94A; Image: 196. (Ancestry.com).
“Passed Away” Decatur Daily Republican (Decatur, Illinois) October 13, 1887, Thur, p. 3. (Newspapers.com).
“The Final Reward. Edward F. Hartley, the Well-Known Photographer, Answers Death’s Dread Summons.” Daily Inter Ocean (Chicago, IL) Vol. 16, Issue 199. October 10, 1887, p. 5. (Genealogybank.com).
Family member… Not sure who it is yet, but I’m working on it.
Okeedoke, will stay tuned 🙂
I have a wonderful Hartley Cabinet Card of a married couple. The cabinet card is centered in a fabulous shadow box frame glass topped. Surrounding the cabinet card marriage photo is the tiara of flowers worn by the bride and also the corsage worn by the groom. It is amazing and would love to share a photograph here but do not know how to do that.
Hi J., I don’t see how you can do it in the comment but if you send it to my website email I’ll put it in the post. Sounds beautiful! email: anne.laurelcottage13553@gmail.com.
Thank you for this history of the Hartley photography business. I have a few old family portraits produced at this studio, all of them 1887 at the earliest (given our immigration history), so I am curious about whether or not this photography studio continued to operate after E.F. Hartley’s death in 1887? If it did in fact close, this actually helps me to date the photographs we have to no later than 1887. Thank you!
You’re very welcome, Carol, and thanks for your question! I added a short news clip on Edward Hartley’s will, which mentions Edward’s brother, Charles F. Hartley (presumably of Chicago). A quick check in city directories finds a few entries for Charles as photographer, but not sure about the address and if this person is the brother….Stay tuned, will update in a few days.
any other info about whether the brother continued to operate after 1887 using the same Hartley Portraits? can I send you my photo to guess the date taken?
Hi luckygirl….sure, you can send me the photo…emailing you now. Please send the reverse side as well 🙂 Anne
I Have a great cabinet card from Hartley with your backstamp. Oh and I counted 8 Hartleys on the back!
Thanks, Nelson. I must have meant seven Hartleys just on the illustration of the building. Updated the post to clarify. 🙂 Anne
I have the cabinet card that I believe is Butch Cassidy and possibly some of the earps from hartley’s.
Thanks for this blog post. I have an old card de vista from “Hartley, West State Street, Opposite Court House”. The antique photo album (my family) lived in Jacksonville, Illinois and the court house is on West State Street.
Hi Mark, you’re very welcome and thanks so much for you comment. And I think you might mean carte de visite? Those were the smaller ones which were about 2 and 1/2 x 4 and 1/8 inches (translated as “visiting cards” in English). The larger ones were the cabinet cards. Either way, good for you that you have that photo album!
We just found a photograph of one of my ancestors that has no name on it. It shows a younger-than-middle aged man in a US Army uniform with an infantry hat. It was taken at “Hartley’s” at “163 State St., Chicago.” Do you have any record of Hartley’s photography at that address? If so, when?
Hi Paul,
There’s a Charles F. Hartley, photographer, 7th floor. 163 State. (Residence address 253 Ontario in 1897, and 85 Rush in 1898.) I don’t see anything for 1895 or 1899. And the 1900 city directory shows 214 State for his business address.
Sources: The Chicago Directory Co.’s The Lakeside Annual Directory of the City of Chicago – years 1896, 1897, 1898, 1900.
Looking into Edward’s family, he had a brother, Charles F., born in OH about 1853. Charles was working in Edward’s studio on W. Madison Street in the year 1882, as reported in a newspaper article dated Oct 23, 1894 which I’ll attach for you in an email. (Some other directory years show he was working for Edward, also.) So, it sounds like it would have been the brother who produced that photo that you have, circa 1896 – 1898.
Best regards,
Anne